Pumpkin Pie
3UncommonDemand: 2#573 most valuable
Pumpkin Pie is currently valued at 3 in Murder Mystery 2, making it the #573 most valuable tracked item. It is an Uncommon item. Values reflect trader consensus as of 19 October 2026. Before you accept any offer for Pumpkin Pie, run both sides through the WFL calculator. A fair trade lands within about 10% of even.
Fair trades for Pumpkin Pie
Items worth about the same, one-for-one swaps with these are close to fair:
| Item | Value | Rarity | Demand |
|---|---|---|---|
 Potion | 3 | Uncommon | 1 |
 Clown | 3 | Uncommon | 1 |
 Carrot | 3 | Uncommon | 2 |
 Chick | 3 | Common | 2 |
 Spring | 3 | Rare | 2 |
 Palms (Gun) | 3 | Legendary | 2 |